Welcome

Dennis Jones is a Jamaican-born international economist, who has lived most of the time in the UK and USA, and latterly in Guinea, west Africa. He moved back to the Caribbean in 2007. This blog contains his observations on life on this small eastern Caribbean island, as well as views on life and issues on a broader landscape, especially the Caribbean and Africa.

*NEW!!! LISTEN TO BLOG POSTS FEATURE ADDED!!!*

*PLEASE READ COMMENTS POLICY--NO ANONYMOUS COMMENTS, PLEASE*

*REFERENCES TO NEWSPAPER OR MEDIA REPORTS ARE USUALLY FOLLOWED BY LINKS TO ACTUAL REPORTS*

*IMAGES MAY BE ENLARGED BY CLICKING ON THEM*

*SUBSCRIBE TO THIS BLOG BY E-MAIL (SEE BOX IN SIDE BAR)*


______________________________________

**You may contact me by e-mail at livinginbarbados[at]gmail[dot]com**
Showing posts with label Elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Elections. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Will You Take Me To The Ball? Political Indecision In The UK Shows How MPs Can Waltz

The indecisive result from last week's General Election in the UK put into sharp focus what happens when the rhetoric of adversarial politics as practised in many of the Westminster-based parliamentary systems comes face to face with an electorate that is not polarised. The UK does not have a history of coalition politics at the national level, in contrast to experiences in many of its European neighbours. Much of that is a reflection of the first-past-the-post system as well as the skewed outcomes that come from the allocation of constituencies. In short, voting shares do not result in similar allocation of seats and therefore the claims on power. It has been a while since any UK government had an actual majority of votes. Many European countries get coalitions because their proportional voting systems recognize that overall majorities are not often the result for which people vote and therefore combining to make a majority is more a logical outcome needed to get governments formed. Whether the coalitions make sense in terms of political leanings and policy agendas is another issue.

In the UK, the mad electoral system has just about run its course, where a hung Parliament seemed likely for a long time before the voting, and turned out to be the outcome. Conservatives gained 306 seats of a possible 650 [see BBC report on results] (47% of total seats, with 36% of the vote). Labour had 258 seats (40% of seats, with 29% of votes). The Liberal Democrats got a measly 57 seats (9% of total, with 23% of votes). Other parties gained 28 seats (4 1/2% of total, with 12% of votes). That shows as clearly as you need that the system does not give people what they vote for.

It is interesting to watch the process of 'king making', with the Liberal Democrat party getting the 3rd highest share of votes and now meeting its suitors. First, its negotiating team went to the tent of the party with the largest vote share (Conservatives, right of centre)), but with whom the Lib Dems (a centre-left party) have fewer 'natural' policy overlaps. Then, yesterday, with PM Gordon Brown's promise to remove himself from leadership opening the way for formal negotiations with the Lib Dems, they naturally went to sit in the Labour (left of centre) tent, where they will have more policy overlaps. For the Lib Dems, the real test should be electoral reform, as this should give them a more assured political future if they have some variant of proportional representation which would translate their strong vote into Parliamentary power. But, electoral reform was not a major issue during the election, which was dominated by economic issues and immigration. The sweetener for the Lib Dems that the Tories have now offered is a promised referendum so that the people can decide.

Whether those who voted for the separate parties will be happy with any coalition formed is another issue that has to be dealt with by each party and there are some poisoned chalice situations waiting to be met. One also has to think that 'stable government', if there is a Labour-Lib Dem pact, will depend on the support of other small parties. It will be a muddle to get this all stitched up quickly, and speed is not really the thing that is important politically, despite lots of media and financial market pressures to do a deal quickly.

For the Caribbean, the thought that comes to mind is whether we have been served well with the Westminster-style system and local politicians' efforts to polarise voters, even though in many of the region's English-speaking countries the differences are not poles apart. Trinidad's election is now running, and for fun, I have been playing with the idea of how the lack of any overall majority there may play out. It's worth watching the UK dance for both style and substance and lessons that it may offer.

Saturday, March 06, 2010

Advance Notice--Unity Bar Lunchtime Lecture: March 12, 2010

The next lecture in the series will be delivered on Friday, March 12, 2010, by Mr. Peter Wickham, Political Analyst and Director of Caribbean Development Research Services (CADRES), at the the Auditorium, George Street, Belleville, St. Michael; his topic will be "Counting the Cost of Elections in the Caribbean: Lessons from Dominica and St. Kitts". As usual lunch will be served from 12.30 pm and the lecture will start at 1.00 pm.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

All change in Barbados

There will be a new government leading Barbados, and the new Prime Minister will be David Thompson. Barbados has followed the trend in all but one Caribbean election in the past 12 month and voted out the government. The Democratic Labour Party (DLP or Dems) won 20 seats over only 10 seats won by the Barbados Labour Party (BLP or Bees), and will form a government for the first time in 14 years.

While PM Owen Arthur and deputy PM Mia Mottley
safely held their seats, the 12% swing to the Dems led to a slew of defeats, including for nine ministers (Reginald Farley, Liz Thompson, Anthony Wood, Noel Lynch, Kerrie Symmonds, Trevor Prescod, Clyde Mascoll, Jerome Walcott and Rev. Joseph Atherley). Amongst the notable fallen heads were Clyde Mascoll (who had won as a Dem in 2003, defected to the Bees two years ago, and now has a chance to find new work). His defection was amongst several factors weighing against him, as was a simmering scandal over his role, financial or otherwise, in a company named Hardwood Housing. Tourism Minister Noel Lynch also lost his seat; many observers have said that the moment that Minister Lynch stormed out of a radio call-in program during spring last year over a question about his personal wealth the writing was on the wall. Some are contending that the late public push by the Dems' support of introducing integrity legislation was a cause of a late surge in support.

For detailed results you can see Nation News interactive poll results. Some of the races were very close and two seats needed recounts before falling in favour of BLP. Some of the following details may change, but at writing, St, Michael West Central went to the Dems' James Paul by 1 vote! St. Joseph went to BLP's Dale Marshall by 10 votes. St. Andrew went to BLP's George Payne by 50 votes.

It appears that the Dems did a good job of getting out the voters, especially the youths.

Barbados Election: Democratic Labour Party wins. "It's time for change"

It's about 1.30 in the morning and the overall results are in. Owen Arthur and the Barbados Labour Party will not have a fourth consecutive term, and the new prime minister designate is David Thompson, whose Democratic Labour Party won an impressive victory looking set to have 20 seats. There will be at least one recount, but the overall result will not change. Several Cabinet ministers lost their seats, including Clyde Mascoll and Noel Lynch. The outgoing PM was understandably not his usual voluble personality when just interviewed on the radio. Clearly DLP MPs, candidates, and supporters are of course jubilant. The turnout seems to have been good, around 64 percent.

At first blush, it looks as if Peter Wickham and his CADRES poll got the call more or less correct in terms of swing and possible seats for DLP (see previous post). Peter Boxill, who conducted a competing CHAPO/Boxill poll was clearly uncomfortable in the TV studio as the results came in and his poll, which had indicated a BLP win, seemed to take on more and more unreality.

More details tomorrow.

Sunday, January 13, 2008

Election issues in Barbados and Taiwan

Just three very quick updates with a slant on the elections in Barbados.

First, a CHAPO/Boxill poll conducted by two UWI academics (Prof. Ian Boxill and Dion Greenidge) in early January put the BLP ahead of DLP by 41.5% to 36.2%, with a margin of error of +/- 3%. The poll projects that the vote will be between 50-53% for BLP and between 47-50% for DLP, giving BLP a margin of maybe 5 seats. This is not so out of line with the recent CADRES poll (that had a +/- 5% margin of error), not "poles (or polls) apart" as one radio station hails.The two polls indicate that the election will be close. The CHAPO/Boxill poll indicates clearly, as did the CADRES poll, that Owen Arthur has a substantial lead in people's minds as the best leader, with 48% support against David Thompson's 33%. That could be a major factor as over 50% of voters say they will be swayed by consideration of particular MP and choice of Prime Minister. Both polls are also clear that the major (over 50%) voter concern by far is the cost of living, and this is rising. There will be a lot of chewing over the numbers but the voting day is really close and the voting will be very close.

Second, I do not know enough about the various MPs to have a strong view to express here, but one contest will be very close and I feel very heated. That is the race for St. Michael North West, between Clyde Mascoll (BLP) and Christopher Sinckler (DLP). Mr. Mascoll is the government spokesman on economic and financial affairs, but he was elected as DLP MP but crossed the floor two years ago. In the British-type parliamentary system such a change does not require a by-election or renewal of the MP's mandate under his new party's hat. Now voters can have their say about the change of party, whether they really like the candidate, and more. Mr. Mascoll's portfolio is a hot one and his rise to "co-leader" status in the BLP may make him loved by fewer on either side of the party divide. He is quoted in the Sunday Sun as saying to a crowd of BLP supporters "Deep in your hearts, you know I deserve to be a Member of Parliament". These could be prophetic words. This is the race to watch for me.

Third, Taiwan's voters went to the polls this week and elected the opposition Nationalist Party to a landslide victory in legislative elections, winning 81 of 113 seats. This is a big dent for the policies of Taiwan's president Chen Shui-bian and his drive to formalise the de facto independence from the People's Republic of China (PRC). The president resigned immediately as chairman of the ruling Democratic Progressive Party. Some critics point to this policy as having dented Taiwan's competitiveness and greatly increasing tensions with the PRC. Presidential election are due March 22, 2008, and the Nationalists now have a 20% lead with their candidate Ma Ying-jeou. This election victory should be borne in mind when thinking of recent accusations of Barbados' DLP getting funding from Taiwan.

Friday, January 11, 2008

Barbados election fever heating up

Many observers are saying that Barbados' current election campaign is by far the most vigorous and exciting. Remember that in the last election the difference between the two main parties was less than 8,000 votes, but in the distribution of parliamentary seats in the British-inspired first-past-the-post system the BLP gained a huge majority. So, the last election race was very close (see cartoon alongside from Nation front page). Some of this real contest is now spilling into the kind of behaviour that is not common in Barbados at elections or other times. Press reports indicate several assaults of party workers, the latest involving attacks with cutlasses. That is an unwelcome development and those close to the parties need to ensure that if the attackers are true supporters that they be found and duly sanctioned. Fear politics is a slippery slope from which it can be very difficult to return: see Jamaica in our own region.

I am interested how sensitive information gets leaked at election time. Today's papers have DLP ads with copies of checks cashed or deposited in 2003 (around the last election time) by BLP operatives in various guises, including a check made to the PM himself. This is part of the "great debate" on campaign financing, which is less clear cut in Barbados than it could be and got public airing at a DLP rally last night (see Nation report). These may be "large and irregular payments" but there is nothing to show that they were inappropriate. Anyway, it's good politicking. One BLP notable, Dame Billie Miller (whom I always regard as speaking sensibly) called recently for the campaign finance issue to be revisited and clarified.

A CADRES poll published today shows the DLP with a slight lead over BLP, by 35% to 30% voter support, and a 9% swing against the ruling BLP. However, the real dilemma rests with the true "third party", undecided voters, who are some 34%. On leadership, there is still a clear preference for Owen Arthur with 48% support, though down from 52% in October. Opposition leader, David Thompson, however has grown in support with 41%, compared to 29% in October. Support for Mia Mottley (Deputy PM) as possible PM has fallen dramatically, to 7% (from 13%). Support for Clyde Mascoll as possible PM remains low and falling, to 3%.

If the vote were to be based on the election ads then I think the DLP would win as they have the catchier tunes and use a better play on words than the BLP. I like their "Tell David that I with Dem" and "It's time for change" jingles. But I also like the BLP's "Moving with Owen" and "Bees yes. Dems no. To the polls here we go" jingles. All exploit Soca or Crop Over based tunes. But I am also already tired of hearing them every few minutes; now there should be some thought to limit spending on these ads, though I am sure that the radio stations are lapping up the extra revenue.

This is my first time to live through a Caribbean election campaign. Not surprising, it's a party. But I also admire the energy here, with a caravan of party leaders and spokesmen touring the island each evening to make speeches.

I was impressed by some of the BLP proposals to promote health, including allowances for gym membership. Now that is what I could vote for. But I have no vote here.

I will spend part of the weekend with some Bajans whom I know are avid supporters of one party and I will try to gauge how they see things from a partisan viewpoint, and if they can possibly see things from any other viewpoint.

Tuesday, January 08, 2008

Barbados is also going to the polls and to the poles

I have not been ignoring Barbados' general election, which is due to be held on January 15. The announcement came as a nice pre-Christmas present from PM Owen Arthur. As I was off the island I preferred to get back and have a sense of the real fervour that exists. After two days I know that most of the day the radio stations (especially Voice of Barbados) are filled with party political adverts; it seems that every five minutes or less I hear a plug for the "Dems" or the "Bees". The daily newspapers too are flooded with political ads; on 16 pages out of 47 in The Nation and on 11 out of 48 pages in The Advocate today. Some are witty. Some are too cute (DLP ad with mugger unable to get any money from citizen who has spent it all on a basket of groceries--"sky rocketing cost of living" is the message). Some are truly silly (such as DLP ad with PM Arthur's face superimposed on a supposed military dictator's body saying "I am no tyrant"). The issues are as usual getting mixed up with nonsensical activities. For me the best of the latter category concerns the posting of political ads on electricity poles, which Barbados Light and Power tells us creates security issues. Amongst these are the risk that those putting up the illegal posters might fall and hurt themselves. Now who says that business is not caring?

A spate of allegations have flowed over the past few days as well as reports of unsavoury business:
  • BLP accuse DLP of being funded by Taiwanese interests; DLP vigorously deny.
  • PM Owen Arthur accused CLICO Chairman, Leroy Parris of visiting St. Kitts to negotiate with Taiwanese government; he strongly denies (see report in The Nation); Taiwanese diplomats also deny these stories.
  • UWI political science academic, Don Marshall, reports that he received death threats at a BLP meeting.
  • Radio callers were concerned that the sporting of party colours (BLP=red; DLP=yellow) would lead to some increases in election-related violence; but one man reported being pelted with eggs near a party rally and he was in a neutral coloured car and wearing a white shirt.
  • DLP party posters and billboards (placed illegally) were torn down in various locations.
  • DLP concerns that their phones are being tapped.
There has been some slight controversy over PM Arthur naming Clyde Mascoll, the government's front man on economic affairs, as "co-leader", whatever that means. I don't have any idea what that means for Mia Mottley who is officially Deputy PM.

So far I have not heard much that is new except that the "integrity" issue has been put forward by the DLP as a part of its platform. DLP president, David Thompson, stated that no member of a government led by him would take office unless that MP declared his/her assets, and he made a jibe at BLP's Minister of Tourism for refusing to answer questions on his personal wealth during a now infamous Sunday radio call-in show, when the Minister stormed out of the studios.

BLP has an ad where it says "tax cuts" on pensions, plus raising thresholds and allowances on a wide range of allowances. To be paid for how? DLP will consider a range of measures to help curb price increases, including considering removing VAT on electricity usage. Again, to be paid for how?

From my house I get a good dose of the loud electioneering every evening.
Who will win? I could not guess at this stage. If you gauge the noise and rhetoric it will be a dead heat.

Friday, September 14, 2007

Nature's little secrets


That's the motto shown on the vehicle license plates in the British Virgin Islands (BVI). This archipelago of islands is certainly not well known to many of us. But I have the pleasure of being based on one of them, Tortola, for several days, while I teach.
If you like hills, which I do, then this place is heaven, as there are large mounds everywhere. It means driving on roads with lots of steep inclines, and windy bends. But, with a population of only 24,000, the BVI is not too busy and it's easy to enjoy solitude and the breezes. The islands, however, are on an earthquake fault line, and I had my first experience of a tremor last night as a quake measuring 4.6 hit the islands. Reports so far indicate no damage or injuries.

Life here has its immediate oddities. Very strong British links, and vehicles drive on the left, but most are left hand drive and large US SUV-types (needed for the hills). The US dollar is the currency. The islands have become very wealthy in a short space of time. Tourism and financial services are now the economic backbone of the BVI (see link), but new attractions are being sought. There is no major conference centre here yet, so events struggle for the right space (see for instance the forthcoming Business BVI "2007 Women of Power Summit", which will be held at the Community College Resource Centre).

What I found is that the the islands are in a new wave of democracy, having just had general elections on August 20, where the ruling New Democratic Party was ousted by the Virgin Island Party. Incumbents losing is the trend at the moment in the Caribbean region. The BVI will now have its first Premier (instead of a Chief Minister).
In familiarizing myself with Tortola, I found myself attending the first sitting of the new House of Assembly, which was taking place in the island's multi-complex gym as this has more seating space for the general public. The election was not close in terms of seats but the difference in popular vote was close. The new PM, Ralph T. O'Neal, won his seat by a mere 9 votes (see link)! The new government gave a flavour of some of the issues that gnaw away here. Talking of the need for unity, the PM stressed that he will treat supporters of the NDP with compassion, kindness and respect and that will be the practise of all ministers and backbenchers. The Minister of Natural Resources and Labour noted his election as meaning “deliverance for everybody” regardless of race or colour. From what I hear, that song of inclusiveness for foreigners from a Minister who is married to someone from the Dominican Republic, will not be sweet music to the ears of BVIslanders.

While physically very different from Barbados, what I have heard in a few days tells me that many similar issues affect the two places. BVIslanders have their ways, as does every community. Outsiders from elsewhere in the Caribbean say that they have a hard time breaking the barriers of not being "Belongers" or "Born Here". So, Jamaicans, Trinis, Dominicans, Vincentians etc. are trying to make their way economically and socially but find many barriers or points of resistance. However, many of these so-called "Downislanders" are keeping the BVI running, as they provide goods and services across a wide range of areas. Violent crime is becoming more common place, with armed robberies and other crimes appearing more, with the culprits being young men. The cost of living is apparently very high, and people take opportunities to dodge that by visiting St. Thomas in the US Virgin Islands, or Puerto Rico. Online journalism and discussions are thriving (see BVI News and BVI Platinum News, for example).

You can only get the merest impression of a place and its people in a few days, but I will take the weekend to see some more of Tortola and I hope some of the other islands.

Tuesday, September 04, 2007

Jamaica's election results

See my blog, Caribbean Comment, for brief initial comments on the results of yesterday's inconclusive elections.

Friday, July 27, 2007

Election time...in Jamaica


Spending a few days in Jamaica right now is interesting. Many things about Caribbean life are similar across the islands, but some things are very different. One of the similarities is how our politicians try to show themselves to be like "ordinary" people at election time. For us that has to be more than kissing babies. In Jamaica's case, PM Portia Simpson-Miller is always ready to dance on stage at a rally. Opposition leader, Bruce Golding, can be seen sympathizing with a local person's plight.

One of the differences is the presence of political violence around election time. Jamaica will have national elections on August 27, and in the long run in to that date, much of the focus is on whether politically related violence can be kept in check. The parties have signed a Code of Conduct, and we will have to see if that makes any real difference. In the early days, it's clear that there will be violence. The reactions of the parties' spokesmen to any event highlight the animosity that is always there between the ruling People's National Party (PNP) and the oppostion Jamaica Labour Party (JLP). Charges of "liar" come forward very fast. The police have so far come forward with robust responses and statements warning that they will not tolerate attempts to intimidate by residents' blocking access to communities. Reports indicate some candidates have been shot at, and investigations are underway. Graffiti slogans have been daubed on constituency offices (though in one case, the local JLP has arranged for this to removed from PNP property). Grand promises are coming, so too is the need to clarify "misunderstandings", such as the JLP's position on reducing the police force's working week to 40 hours.

So far, the newspapers have found many other things to continue to report besides electioneering events. On television, the evening news seem to focus more on the election-related town meetings, possibily because these look spectacular (with PNP rallies decked in orange and yellow, and PLP rallies decked out in green). The TV electioneering sound bites are not very illuminating. However, some of the studio analysis is really very good, and there is a lesson here for any of the Caribbean countries: the moderator really could keep control of the guests, and they in turn showed good moderation in their desire to hog the lime light and throw accusations. So far, there have been no proposals for a CNN/YouTube debate by the party leaders or candidates, as happened this past week in the USA, but in the Internet age, nothing like this can be ruled out once it has been made possible.

Where Jamaica seems to be following the US is in spending increasing amounts on elections (one estimate indicates that this could reach J$600 million, about US$9 million). Legitimate concerns are raised in this region about who finances politicians, and what influence this can have on outcomes. We do not have the strong limitations on party financing, as in the UK or US (where even with such limits one sees many abuses).

The organization of the elections will be another major issue, and so far measures to ensure secret voting, avoid vote abuse, and minimize intimidation seem to have been well thought out and being put in place properly. That is one of the benefits of having enough time to organize the elections.

Superstition always has its place in Caribbean life. The "magic" of 7s is at play in the Jamaican elections, starting with the choice of date. All eyes watch keenly as any other plays on 7 occur.

I will keep following events when I get back to Barbados, hoping that the violence does not erupt on anything like the worst levels that Jamaica has seen in the past. For others who wish to follow from a distance a good site is Jamaica Elections 2007. It contains profiles of all constituencies, a daily news digest of election coverage, photographs and cartoons (from which I have drawn).